#116 Changes are evaluated at beta freeze while they may have a different contingency deadline
Opened 2 years ago by churchyard. Modified 7 months ago

When we were discussing Fedora 30 incomplete changes I've noticed one thing: the GHC change has a contingency deadline at branching but we are checking it at beta freeze. This makes it impossible to activate the contingency mechanism at the given deadline.

I don't want to add any extra work you @bcotton's plate, but I think something needs to be changed in the change process:

  • either we have all contingency deadlines at beta freeze (or later)
  • or we evaluate the criteria for each change at it's own deadline

@bcotton let me know if I shall keep this here or move to fesco

I think the "evaluate the criteria for each change at its own deadline" option is more appropriate. It is a little more work on my plate, but I think it's the right approach.

It shouldn't be too much effort to note which changes need to be evaluated at which point. I can do that for F31 and beyond. Realistically, there are probably three point where a contingency plan would need to be evaluated: branch, beta freeze, and final freeze. As I work on some new tooling with GSoC students, that might be a good feature to add.

So the new tooling didn't work out. In the meantime, I just added support for including the contingency deadline in the ChangeSet page. This is an incomplete way to address the underlying issue, but it at least improves the visibility somewhat.

Login to comment on this ticket.