#75 Badge Ideas series: Creator (II), Master (III), Guru (IV)
Closed 2 years ago Opened 5 years ago by adamwill.

Creator Description: Your Fedora Badge idea was approved! Congratulations!
Master Description: Your Fedora Badge idea was released! Congratulations!
Guru Description: You had 10 Fedora Badges released! Congratulations!

See #2 for the first badge in the series. This ticket proposes a continuation.

II would be awarded to the reporter of a badge trac ticket when the "Concept approved" checkbox is set (badge passes concept review). This should be expressible with the trac.ticket.update message. III and IV could look for tickets being closed with the "pushed" status for consistency with I through III, or cue off something closer to the bone for technical accuracy, I guess.

Artwork is extrapolated from Badge Muse's, obviously.


Set triaged to 'yes' for all tickets, as I've hit them all already.

Set triaged to 'yes' for all tickets, as I've hit them all already.

just put types back in, we'll try and handle bugs here too, no new trac.

just put types back in, we'll try and handle bugs here too, no new trac.

[[Image(badgemuse_approved.png)]]
[[Image(badgemuse_approved_5.png)]]
[[Image(badgemuse_approved_10.png)]]
Other badges coming soon...

[[Image(badgemuse_approved.png)]]
[[Image(badgemuse_approved_5.png)]]
[[Image(badgemuse_approved_10.png)]]
Other badges coming soon...

[[Image(badgemuse_approved_20.png)]]
[[Image(badgemuse_approved_50.png)]]

[[Image(badgemuse_approved_20.png)]]
[[Image(badgemuse_approved_50.png)]]

@olgalyulko love the artwork!! I am going to wait to approve it until we decide what other badges need/don't need to be made.

I have been thinking about this ticket and the different badges that are being suggested, and I think that we should have one series for having your badge ideas released. Although it can be cool to have more badges, in theory if you are getting the ideas released badge you would naturally also get the corresponding ideas approved badge. That seemed redundant to me, so I did a little research in the badge tickets to see if many badges had concept approved artwork that was not released(only one). And then decided to check how many badges had their concept approved at all and out of all of the badge tickets, only 12 badges have ever had their concept reviewed. We have pushed many badges without concept review. To me that is not worth making a badge series. If anyone has thoughts, please feel free to chime in.

I think that the badge artwork that @olgalyulko will work great for badge ideas released as well

@olgalyulko love the artwork!! I am going to wait to approve it until we decide what other badges need/don't need to be made.

I have been thinking about this ticket and the different badges that are being suggested, and I think that we should have one series for having your badge ideas released. Although it can be cool to have more badges, in theory if you are getting the ideas released badge you would naturally also get the corresponding ideas approved badge. That seemed redundant to me, so I did a little research in the badge tickets to see if many badges had concept approved artwork that was not released(only one). And then decided to check how many badges had their concept approved at all and out of all of the badge tickets, only 12 badges have ever had their concept reviewed. We have pushed many badges without concept review. To me that is not worth making a badge series. If anyone has thoughts, please feel free to chime in.

I think that the badge artwork that @olgalyulko will work great for badge ideas released as well

Replying to [comment:6 riecatnor]:

I have been thinking about this ticket and the different badges that are
being suggested, and I think that we should have one series for having your
badge ideas released. Although it can be cool to have more badges, in theory
if you are getting the ideas released badge you would naturally also get the
corresponding ideas approved badge. That seemed redundant to me, so I did a
little research in the badge tickets to see if many badges had concept
approved artwork that was not released(only one). And then decided to check
how many badges had their concept approved at all and out of all of the badge
tickets, only 12 badges have ever had their concept reviewed. We have pushed
many badges without concept review.

Interesting.

To me that is not worth making a badge series. If anyone has thoughts, please
feel free to chime in.

I agree.

I think that the badge artwork that @olgalyulko will work great for badge
ideas released as well

Me too!

Replying to [comment:6 riecatnor]:

I have been thinking about this ticket and the different badges that are
being suggested, and I think that we should have one series for having your
badge ideas released. Although it can be cool to have more badges, in theory
if you are getting the ideas released badge you would naturally also get the
corresponding ideas approved badge. That seemed redundant to me, so I did a
little research in the badge tickets to see if many badges had concept
approved artwork that was not released(only one). And then decided to check
how many badges had their concept approved at all and out of all of the badge
tickets, only 12 badges have ever had their concept reviewed. We have pushed
many badges without concept review.

Interesting.

To me that is not worth making a badge series. If anyone has thoughts, please
feel free to chime in.

I agree.

I think that the badge artwork that @olgalyulko will work great for badge
ideas released as well

Me too!

Approving the artwork for Badge ideas released, great job @olgalyulko!

Approving the artwork for Badge ideas released, great job @olgalyulko!

The bitmap image is bigger than the others (or the margin is smaller).

The bitmap image is bigger than the others (or the margin is smaller).

A higher resolution bitmap image of the badge (the current one is a lower resolution from all other badges)
badgemuse_approved.2.png

A higher resolution bitmap image of the badge (the current one is a lower resolution from all other badges)
badgemuse_approved.2.png

Replying to [comment:10 churchyard]:

The bitmap image is bigger than the others (or the margin is smaller).
I've also noticed the same thing. I uploaded a higher resolution bitmap image and attached it to this ticket. Should be as easy as updating the PNG that is on the servers.

Replying to [comment:10 churchyard]:

The bitmap image is bigger than the others (or the margin is smaller).
I've also noticed the same thing. I uploaded a higher resolution bitmap image and attached it to this ticket. Should be as easy as updating the PNG that is on the servers.

Metadata Update from @adamwill:
- Issue tagged with: meta

2 years ago

badgemuse_approved.png
badgemuse_approved_5.png
badgemuse_approved_10.png
badgemuse_approved_20.png
[badgemuse_approved_50.png](/Fedora-Badges/issue/raw/a044330fb9feac4bd1c385c29815c59db4f4782fc8615f4b80313c13c22db61a-badgemuse_approved_50.png

Artwork updated - should have the correct spacing now. Can someone please push these and close the ticket? Thanks!

Metadata Update from @riecatnor:
- Custom field artwork adjusted to has_concept
- Custom field concept_review_passed adjusted to passed (was: 0)
- Custom field has_complete_yaml reset (from None)
- Custom field has_description adjusted to on (was: 1)
- Custom field has_name adjusted to on (was: 1)
- Custom field needs_manual_award reset (from 0)
- Custom field triaged adjusted to on (was: 1)
- Issue close_status updated to: None

2 years ago

Oh, I will not, because this repository does not contain the badges and fedorahosted is dead. What is the repo for the badges?

Found the repo, but I no longer has push rights, so created a PR here: https://pagure.io/fedora-badges-assets/pull-request/2

Metadata Update from @churchyard:
- Custom field has_complete_yaml reset (from false)
- Custom field needs_manual_award reset (from false)
- Issue status updated to: Closed (was: Open)

2 years ago

Login to comment on this ticket.

Metadata