BetaFE +1

BetaFE +1

BetaFE +1

There's no harm in including FTBFS fix (also no real reason as opposed to FTI fixes).

BetaFE 0

I don't see a compelling reason to include this (as opposed to a FTI fix), but I'm not going to argue about it.

BetaFE -1

We have to keep some standards around here, darnit. =) The default should be not to grant FE/blocker status. That's what a freeze means. There is a reasonable justification for FEs for FTI, there is no reasonable justification for FEs for FTBFS alone.

There is a reasonable justification for FEs for FTI, there is no reasonable justification for FEs for FTBFS alone.

I always forget which one to +1, so I +1 both :-D

Also, I somewhat take the approach of "sure, +1" unless it looks risky. But the opposite is probably better, especially to decrease the load of proposed FEs.

To make Adam happy and keep the standards:
BetaFE -1

BetaFE -1

AGREED RejectedBetaFE There is no point in getting FTBFS fixes through the FE process.

The following votes have been closed:

• Rejected BetaFreezeException (+2, 1, -3)
  • +1 by geraldosimiao, frantisekz
  • 0 by bcotton
  • -1 by kparal, adamwill, lruzicka

Release F38 is no longer tracked by BlockerBugs, closing this ticket.