PR#806: Retire Long Life to Pagure badges - fedora-badges

fedora-badges

#806 Retire Long Life to Pagure badges

Merged a year ago by gui1ty. Opened 3 years ago by oturpe.

oturpe/fedora-badges retire-pagure-long-life into master

Otto Urpelainen • 3 years ago

66c1998

retired_rules/pagure-long-life-01.yml ~~rules/pagure-long-life-01.yml~~

file renamed

		`@@ -1,5 +1,11 @@`
		`%YAML 1.2`
		`---`
		`+ # Retired due to the following issues:`
		`+ # 1. If the message contains commits from multiple authors, commits count per`
		`+ # author is not available.`
		`+ # 2. Even if commit count per author was available, there is no way to evaluate`
		`+ # criteria separately for each author.`
		`+ # 3. Synchronizing forks leads to the same commits being counted more than once`

		`# This is some metadata about the badge`
		`name: Long Life to Pagure (Pagure I)`

retired_rules/pagure-long-life-10.yml ~~rules/pagure-long-life-10.yml~~

file renamed

		`@@ -1,5 +1,11 @@`
		`%YAML 1.2`
		`---`
		`+ # Retired due to the following issues:`
		`+ # 1. If the message contains commits from multiple authors, commits count per`
		`+ # author is not available.`
		`+ # 2. Even if commit count per author was available, there is no way to evaluate`
		`+ # criteria separately for each author.`
		`+ # 3. Synchronizing forks leads to the same commits being counted more than once.`

		`# This is some metadata about the badge`
		`name: Long Life to Pagure (Pagure II)`

retired_rules/pagure-long-life-1000.yml ~~rules/pagure-long-life-1000.yml~~

file renamed

		`@@ -1,5 +1,11 @@`
		`%YAML 1.2`
		`---`
		`+ # Retired due to the following issues:`
		`+ # 1. If the message contains commits from multiple authors, commits count per`
		`+ # author is not available.`
		`+ # 2. Even if commit count per author was available, there is no way to evaluate`
		`+ # criteria separately for each author.`
		`+ # 3. Synchronizing forks leads to the same commits being counted more than once.`

		`# This is some metadata about the badge`
		`name: Long Life to Pagure (Pagure VI)`

retired_rules/pagure-long-life-150.yml ~~rules/pagure-long-life-150.yml~~

file renamed

		`@@ -1,5 +1,11 @@`
		`%YAML 1.2`
		`---`
		`+ # Retired due to the following issues:`
		`+ # 1. If the message contains commits from multiple authors, commits count per`
		`+ # author is not available.`
		`+ # 2. Even if commit count per author was available, there is no way to evaluate`
		`+ # criteria separately for each author.`
		`+ # 3. Synchronizing forks leads to the same commits being counted more than once.`

		`# This is some metadata about the badge`
		`name: Long Life to Pagure (Pagure IV)`

retired_rules/pagure-long-life-50.yml ~~rules/pagure-long-life-50.yml~~

file renamed

		`@@ -1,5 +1,11 @@`
		`%YAML 1.2`
		`---`
		`+ # Retired due to the following issues:`
		`+ # 1. If the message contains commits from multiple authors, commits count per`
		`+ # author is not available.`
		`+ # 2. Even if commit count per author was available, there is no way to evaluate`
		`+ # criteria separately for each author.`
		`+ # 3. Synchronizing forks leads to the same commits being counted more than once.`

		`# This is some metadata about the badge`
		`name: Long Life to Pagure (Pagure III)`

retired_rules/pagure-long-life-500.yml ~~rules/pagure-long-life-500.yml~~

file renamed

		`@@ -1,5 +1,11 @@`
		`%YAML 1.2`
		`---`
		`+ # Retired due to the following issues:`
		`+ # 1. If the message contains commits from multiple authors, commits count per`
		`+ # author is not available.`
		`+ # 2. Even if commit count per author was available, there is no way to evaluate`
		`+ # criteria separately for each author.`
		`+ # 3. Synchronizing forks leads to the same commits being counted more than once.`

		`# This is some metadata about the badge`
		`name: Long Life to Pagure (Pagure V)`

oturpe commented 3 years ago

These badges do not work as they should for the following reasons:

If the message contains commits from multiple authors, commits count per author is not available.
Even if commit count per author was available, there is no way to evaluate the criteria separately for each author.
Rebasing in forks leads to the same commits being counted more than once, without the badge recipient actually doing anything themself.

Item 1 could be solved by simple extension of schema so that Pagure would include the count per author. If it was the only problem, there would be no need to retire these rules.

Item 2 has the worst effect by far. It has lead to many users having the highest level badge only because they happened to appear as an author in a message that also included a prominent committer. Fixing it would require extension of the rules language in fedbadges backend. It is unclear how difficult that would be.

Item 3 would require more changes to messages emitted by Pagure. A way to distinguish between original work and it being reapplied by others would be needed. Perhaps comparing 'agent' and 'author' would work. But it is unclear if fedbadges backend allows such expressions.

All in all, the rules for Pagure badges are specified in a way that is difficult to implement correctly. Since currently badges are awarded to users that have not earned them and nobody seems to be willing to put effort to fix the situation, it is the best to simply retire the rules.

oturpe commented 3 years ago

Fixes issues: #714, #692

gui1ty commented a year ago

Thanks for the detailed bug report and PR and sorry that it took so long for someone to respond.

I think we'll have to re-evaluate some badges in the future. But first we need an update, reliable backend. In the spirit of putting out fires, I will merge this for now.