= Badge Metadata =
= Badge background =
= Artwork concepts =
Something like this ? <img alt="491_exp01.png" src="https://pagure.io/Fedora-Badges/issue/raw/files/5e4b8cdcae87ac249740ce2d43499a26e0330b2ad250799459fb2dd3aaa8dabd-491_exp01.png" />
Something like this ? <img alt="491_exp01.png" src="//issue/raw/files/5e4b8cdcae87ac249740ce2d43499a26e0330b2ad250799459fb2dd3aaa8dabd-491_exp01.png" />
[[Image(https://fedorahosted.org/fedora-badges/raw-attachment/ticket/491/491_exp01.png)]]
Setting artwork status as proposed, CCing some members of the Design Team for review. :) I also really like the looks of this one so far too!
attachment 491_exp01.svg
I really like the concept of this; super creative! I worry a little bit though about the size of the text in the speech bubble and the size of the flying fedora logos. Maybe try a version with less of the logos to make room to bump up the size of the speech bubble/ text and to bump up the size of the flying fedoras so that they will be able to been seen a bit easier at the generally small scale of a badge?
attachment <img alt="491_exp02.png" src="//issue/raw/files/a0bfc0deb75d55f178c66a2a0dc125a25bdeed62cae18baf18d75e3d6887e834-491_exp02.png" />
attachment <img alt="491_exp02.png" src="https://pagure.io/Fedora-Badges/issue/raw/files/a0bfc0deb75d55f178c66a2a0dc125a25bdeed62cae18baf18d75e3d6887e834-491_exp02.png" />
attachment <img alt="491_exp02.2.png" src="//issue/raw/files/4a70adb552e516c6294a06004303c3472cf9ebf482f04527048893ded05c4490-491_exp02.2.png" />
attachment <img alt="491_exp02.2.png" src="https://pagure.io/Fedora-Badges/issue/raw/files/4a70adb552e516c6294a06004303c3472cf9ebf482f04527048893ded05c4490-491_exp02.2.png" />
Replying to [comment:3 maryshak1996]:
Thanks maryshak1996, I have made the suggested changes, Something like this? [[Image(https://fedorahosted.org/fedora-badges/raw-attachment/ticket/491/491_exp02.2.png)]]
@a2batic, this looks a lot stronger I think; the design is much more easily seen now :)
+1 on the general idea from me. :)
attachment <img alt="491_exp02_02.png" src="https://pagure.io/Fedora-Badges/issue/raw/files/ca66a455ddd3ad7073feadf5c85452a331cef7bd5a5083f940d0a0768f249bf7-491_exp02_02.png" />
attachment <img alt="491_exp02_02.png" src="//issue/raw/files/ca66a455ddd3ad7073feadf5c85452a331cef7bd5a5083f940d0a0768f249bf7-491_exp02_02.png" />
attachment <img alt="491_exp02_03.png" src="//issue/raw/files/58ffb6778d19b921f7cbf171ccebb92eb38778e64fa7332da35d4070c3c933e3-491_exp02_03.png" />
attachment <img alt="491_exp02_03.png" src="https://pagure.io/Fedora-Badges/issue/raw/files/58ffb6778d19b921f7cbf171ccebb92eb38778e64fa7332da35d4070c3c933e3-491_exp02_03.png" />
attachment <img alt="491_exp02_04.png" src="//issue/raw/files/1c776f89513252aeb2a6c60be4482684fa1e063a8bf80755efbb9bc4d0d75a5d-491_exp02_04.png" />
attachment <img alt="491_exp02_04.png" src="https://pagure.io/Fedora-Badges/issue/raw/files/1c776f89513252aeb2a6c60be4482684fa1e063a8bf80755efbb9bc4d0d75a5d-491_exp02_04.png" />
attachment <img alt="491_exp02_05.png" src="//issue/raw/files/46a87b505693ddf71a5967381f653cc7c75e3eedfd0c2d32a5fe80865278e237-491_exp02_05.png" />
attachment <img alt="491_exp02_05.png" src="https://pagure.io/Fedora-Badges/issue/raw/files/46a87b505693ddf71a5967381f653cc7c75e3eedfd0c2d32a5fe80865278e237-491_exp02_05.png" />
attachment <img alt="491_exp02_01.png" src="https://pagure.io/Fedora-Badges/issue/raw/files/d5d46984cfd8c897639fb833095e1c0362e91d7f728616e941bb146f1ec1ff4d-491_exp02_01.png" />
attachment <img alt="491_exp02_01.png" src="//issue/raw/files/d5d46984cfd8c897639fb833095e1c0362e91d7f728616e941bb146f1ec1ff4d-491_exp02_01.png" />
[[Image(https://fedorahosted.org/fedora-badges/raw-attachment/ticket/491/491_exp02_01.png)]] [[Image(https://fedorahosted.org/fedora-badges/raw-attachment/ticket/491/491_exp02_02.png)]] [[Image(https://fedorahosted.org/fedora-badges/raw-attachment/ticket/491/491_exp02_03.png)]] [[Image(https://fedorahosted.org/fedora-badges/raw-attachment/ticket/491/491_exp02_04.png)]] [[Image(https://fedorahosted.org/fedora-badges/raw-attachment/ticket/491/491_exp02_05.png)]]
Replying to [comment:7 a2batic]:
Hey a2batic! Looking good! But please check in with the badges design guidelines https://fedorahosted.org/fedora-badges/attachment/wiki/DesignResources/styleguide_full.pdf; you have many elements that are way too tiny right now. Badges are not so big themselves, so you can see - on some of the 'bugs' are not visible at all. Maybe go for something minimalistic? I'm not so sure on the concept of the whole Fedora being a bug.. You can try using just the shape + adding wings to it and thicker outline. Also the background green doesn't seem to be from the badges palette, is it?
Looking forward to your design!
attachment <img alt="491_exp03_01.png" src="https://pagure.io/Fedora-Badges/issue/raw/files/60177a7ba1cf4a5ac0b5dbd6a586189b383beb6cc4e4808fcb196bc4c65bde26-491_exp03_01.png" />
attachment <img alt="491_exp03_01.png" src="//issue/raw/files/60177a7ba1cf4a5ac0b5dbd6a586189b383beb6cc4e4808fcb196bc4c65bde26-491_exp03_01.png" />
Replying to [comment:8 mleonova]:
Replying to [comment:7 a2batic]: Hey a2batic! Looking good! But please check in with the badges design guidelines https://fedorahosted.org/fedora-badges/attachment/wiki/DesignResources/styleguide_full.pdf; you have many elements that are way too tiny right now. Badges are not so big themselves, so you can see - on some of the 'bugs' are not visible at all. Maybe go for something minimalistic? I'm not so sure on the concept of the whole Fedora being a bug.. You can try using just the shape + adding wings to it and thicker outline. Also the background green doesn't seem to be from the badges palette, is it? Looking forward to your design!
Thanks @mleonova !! I have come up with one more concept. [[Image(https://fedorahosted.org/fedora-badges/raw-attachment/ticket/491/491_exp03_01.png)]] or [[Image(https://fedorahosted.org/fedora-badges/raw-attachment/ticket/491/491_exp04_01.png)]]
attachment <img alt="491_exp04_01.png" src="https://pagure.io/Fedora-Badges/issue/raw/files/325232eeb450228db67ac631c1f4bd25437e8dbfdec6dc9ccb8be6d26e8ad5b1-491_exp04_01.png" />
attachment <img alt="491_exp04_01.png" src="//issue/raw/files/325232eeb450228db67ac631c1f4bd25437e8dbfdec6dc9ccb8be6d26e8ad5b1-491_exp04_01.png" />
Heya, @a2batic! This looks much better to me! Great stuff! Lets improve it some more: try 'zooming in' on the panda - so that it wouldn't end so abruptly in the middle of the badge - just make it bigger (or draw the rest of it). Also check out the Quality badges categories and backgrounds in the Style Guide, page 9. This probably qualifies as the 'proven tester' series? Looking forward to seeing your design!
attachment <img alt="491_exp05.png" src="https://pagure.io/Fedora-Badges/issue/raw/files/007d99d20e27fe45b2c3dfafb148d0c4767b9b3036db490fc251e50e162ba180-491_exp05.png" />
attachment <img alt="491_exp05.png" src="//issue/raw/files/007d99d20e27fe45b2c3dfafb148d0c4767b9b3036db490fc251e50e162ba180-491_exp05.png" />
Replying to [comment:10 mleonova]:
Heya, @a2batic! This looks much better to me! Great stuff! Lets improve it some more: try 'zooming in' on the panda - so that it wouldn't end so abruptly in the middle of the badge - just make it bigger (or draw the rest of it). Also check out the Quality badges categories and backgrounds in the Style Guide, page 9. This probably qualifies as the 'proven tester' series? Looking forward to seeing your design! Hi mleonova, thanks for reviewing :) What about this ? [[Image(https://fedorahosted.org/fedora-badges/raw-attachment/ticket/491/491_exp05.png)]]
Hi, a2batic! This is much better! We reviewed your design and have some suggestions: - there shouldn't be any space left between the panda and the lower edge of the inner circle. Consider either drawing the rest of the panda or make this one bigger and clip it. Should you need more info on clipping, check this tut http://www.ryanlerch.org/blog/inkscape-how-the-clip-function-works-mini-tutorial/ - on a bg like that, it may be more successful with a darker stroke and white letter - the magnifying glass could be grey, and instead of a white stroke, use a darker grey and a light grey on the inside
Metadata Update from @jflory7: - Issue assigned to a2batic - Issue tagged with: qa
Hey @mleonova, thanks for reviewing , here is the improved design. <img alt="491_exp04_02.png" src="/Fedora-Badges/issue/raw/89181e856748dc21384ecf23f0eaf1953a08a5e40d7ed2a3a7b0f4a533026c3d-491_exp04_02.png" />
<img alt="491_exp04_01.svg" src="/Fedora-Badges/issue/raw/d223661561ca3f6dcd6f1a9389217b93d7876638501fb09fdcacb3ba17974d00-491_exp04_01.svg" />
Hi! Looks pretty great! Huge improvement if I remember the older design correctly. It would look even better if the magnifying glass was clipped to be the shape of the badge and if it had a thicker stroke (>1.5px as specified in badge design guidelines) . What do you think?
Metadata Update from @mleonova: - Custom field artwork adjusted to has_concept - Custom field concept_review_passed adjusted to passed (was: 1) - Custom field has_complete_yaml reset (from None) - Custom field has_description adjusted to on (was: 1) - Custom field has_name adjusted to on (was: 1) - Custom field needs_manual_award reset (from 0) - Custom field triaged adjusted to on (was: 1) - Issue close_status updated to: None
Hi @mleonova, thanks for reviewing, I think it will look much better. Here is the edited one. What are your thoughts?
<img alt="491_exp04_03.png" src="/Fedora-Badges/issue/raw/fa5e53efd4f46b1953365d78994e77d72211884cd0fa219ee41775e7bdaac6cc-491_exp04_03.png" />
Metadata Update from @riecatnor: - Custom field artwork adjusted to has_draft (was: has_concept) - Custom field has_complete_yaml reset (from false) - Custom field needs_manual_award reset (from false)
Metadata Update from @riecatnor: - Custom field has_complete_yaml reset (from false) - Custom field needs_manual_award reset (from false) - Issue tagged with: quality
hi @a2batic, looking good with the spyglass cropped. Maybe reposition it so the bottom part is cropped by the badge area instead of just poking out. Can you try a version where the spyglass stroke is increased? Also, @mleonova mentioned earlier, the text "1" you are using is not standing off of the background because they are both light in color. Try using a contrasting outer color and a white letter, similar to this badge: https://badges.fedoraproject.org/badge/froglet
Metadata Update from @riecatnor: - Custom field has_complete_yaml reset (from false) - Custom field needs_manual_award reset (from false)
Closing this ticket due to inactivity during Badges virtual hackfest. Please reopen if their is renewed interest. Thanks!
Metadata Update from @riecatnor: - Custom field has_complete_yaml reset (from false) - Custom field needs_manual_award reset (from false) - Issue close_status updated to: declined - Issue status updated to: Closed (was: Open)
Login to comment on this ticket.